Holiday Gambling: Why You Bet Matters More Than How Much
The Surprising Psychology of Sports Gambling
Are you thinking about placing a little wager on a football game this holiday season? With the rapid growth and normalization of sports gambling across the United States and Canada, betting on a game is more common than ever. But what are the real reasons people gamble?
Most would assume it’s simply for fun, to make a game more exciting, or for the chance to win money. But what if the most important metric for gambling risk isn’t on a bank statement, but in the unseen emotions driving the bet?
A recent study of over 900 sports bettors reveals a more complex picture, uncovering deeper psychological motivations that separate casual fun from problematic behavior. The findings challenge our basic assumptions about gambling risk. This article will break down the five most impactful takeaways from this research, revealing that the “why” behind a bet is far more important than the “how much.”
1. Your Reason for Betting Matters More Than How Much You Spend
One of the study’s most unexpected findings was the relationship between mental health, betting habits, and gambling problems. The research showed that greater anxiety and depression were strongly linked to the severity of a person’s gambling problems. However, these emotional states were not significantly related to the total amount of money a person spent or the total number of bets they made.
This insight reframes how we should think about risk. It’s not just about the financial footprint of betting, but the emotional impetus behind it.
According to the study, the true indicator of risk isn’t found in a bettor’s bank statement, but in the emotional state that drives them to bet in the first place.
This is a critical distinction. It shifts the focus from a purely financial view of problem gambling to a psychological one, suggesting that the “why” you bet is a more telling sign of risk than the “how much” you spend.
Are you exploring your trauma? Do you feel your childhood experiences were detrimental to your current mental or physical health? Utilize this free, validated, self-report questionnaire to find out.
2. The Crucial Difference: Gambling for Fun vs. Betting to Escape
The study identified two key motivations that drive people to bet, each with vastly different outcomes:
- Enhancement Motives: Betting to increase positive emotions. This is the classic reason—placing a wager to add to the thrill and enjoyment of watching a game.
- Coping Motives: Betting to reduce or escape from negative feelings, such as anxiety, stress, or depression.
The results linked to each motive were counter-intuitive.
This revealed a fascinating paradox: while betting to enhance the fun of a game was linked to placing bets more often, it was simultaneously associated with fewer gambling problems. This suggests a clear psychological dividing line between frequent, low-risk engagement and problematic, high-risk behavior.
In stark contrast, betting to cope was the single strongest pathway linking pre-existing anxiety and depression to serious gambling problems.
Crucially, this connection held true even when the researchers accounted for other potential drivers like betting for social or financial reasons, isolating ‘coping’ as the most dangerous motivation. This finding strongly supports the “emotionally vulnerable pathway” model of problem gambling, where individuals use gambling as a maladaptive strategy to manage emotional distress.
3. “In-Play” Gambling Is a Different Beast Entirely
“In-play” sports betting, defined as making wagers during a live game, has exploded in popularity. The study’s findings on this specific group were stark. Compared to bettors who only place wagers before a game starts (single-event or traditional bettors), in-play bettors reported:
- Significantly higher levels of problem gambling.
- Significantly higher scores for both anxiety and depression.
- A higher frequency of betting.
This raises a critical question for researchers: does the high-speed, constant-feedback nature of in-play betting actively create psychological distress, or does it primarily attract individuals already struggling with anxiety and depression who are seeking a powerful distraction?
As professionals, our time is valuable. Dr. Weeks created the Mitigation Aide Research Archive because there isn’t enough focused, data-backed research available in easily digestible formats.
4. For Sports Bettors, Anxiety and Depression Are Often Intertwined
The research observed that in this sample of sports bettors, depression and anxiety were “highly correlated.” In simple terms, participants who scored high on one tended to score high on the other.
The researchers noted that this suggests these conditions are more likely to be comorbid—or occur together—in people who bet on sports. The connection was so strong that the effects of anxiety and depression on gambling behaviors often overlapped. This reinforces the concept of a combined “emotional vulnerability” that can fuel problematic gambling, rather than a single, isolated mental health issue.
5. The Psychological Blueprint Is Surprisingly Consistent Across Genders
The study also examined differences between men and women, revealing a nuanced picture. On the surface, there were clear differences in behavior and emotional states:
- Men engaged in sports betting on significantly more days than women.
- Women reported significantly higher levels of anxiety, depression, and betting for social and coping reasons.
Despite these differences in emotional states and motivations, men and women reported statistically similar levels of overall gambling problems.
The more profound finding was that despite these surface-level differences, the underlying psychological model was the same for both groups.
The core pathways showing how anxiety, depression, and motives lead to gambling problems did not differ between men and women. This suggests that when it comes to the fundamental emotional drivers of problem gambling, gender may not change the blueprint. Interventions, therefore, can likely focus on these consistent psychological drivers for everyone.
Conclusion
This research cuts through the noise of wins, losses, and dollar amounts to deliver a clear message:
Understanding the motivation behind gambling is the key to understanding the risk of it becoming a problem.
While many people bet to enhance their enjoyment of a sport with few negative consequences, the data points to a clear red flag:
The strongest pathway to serious gambling problems isn’t rooted in how much money is spent, but in whether the bettor is motivated by a need to cope with or escape from negative emotions.
Before placing your next bet, it might be worth asking: am I doing this to enhance my fun, or to escape my feelings?
Drop a comment and let us know if you were able to identify any motivations you may have for acting out this holiday season.
Are you a professional looking to stay up-to-date with the latest information on, sex addiction, trauma, and mental health news and research? Or maybe you’re looking for continuing education courses? Then you should stay up-to-date with all of Dr. Jen’s work through her practice’s newsletter!
Do you feel your sexual behavior, or that of someone you love, is out of control? Then you should consult with a professional.
Have you found yourself in legal trouble due to your sexual behavior? Seek assistance before the court mandates it, with Sexual Addiction Treatment Services.
